Will he be sacked? Probably.
Would I sack him? No. Give him the summer to bring in some great players and they could be back in the race next season.
I knew they'd struggle. With Fergie leaving it was always going to take time to rebuild what was a weak team.
If he struggles after ten games next season sack him. But at least give him the chance to rebuild over the summer.
Last edited by rhys (Mon-21-Apr-2014 17:19:54)

Thanks Taker_2004 for the banner!
I think he's pretty much done now. The season's over for them really, Utd & Spurs are fighting it out trying not to get 6th and be in the Europa League next season.
In hindsight replacing the whole backroom staff in one go was the first of many terrible decisions. Not bolstering the team in the summer transfer window was the second, then spunking £30m on Fellaini last minute was the third big mistake.
Then you have putting his faith in the wrong players like Cleverly, thinking Adnan Januzaj was the second coming of Gareth Bale. Smalling & Jones not progressing as players. Paying over the odds for Mata and then constantly playing him out of position on the left wing. Not bothering to play Kagawa at all. Failure to spend more in the January transfer window.
His delusions of the teams performance never helps. Like against Everton he thought Utd were the better side because they had 60% possession. Everton had double the amount of shots on and off target and two goals.
The heavy home losses to Liverpool & Man City last month are what I think sealed his fate. When the Liverpool fans rolled out the "David Moyes: Footballing Genius" banner. There's your embarrassing moment for the back page of the paper, and of course Utd don't want to keep looking like idiots.

They won't get them, but United need a manager who gets the best out of his players like Martinez or Pulis. Those guys take average squads, or worse, and make them competitive. Moyes was an Everton-level manager, he doesn't have what it takes to manage at the top level. Martinez has lost Fellaini, one of Everton's key players last year, and has done better with them than Moyes has been able to for a long time. That says it all. And this is after keeping a poor Wigan side in the league for about five years running and winning an FA cup. The guy gets the job done.
If it were up to me, I'd go for Di Matteo. He may not be the right guy either, but he did great work with Chelsea and people feel sympathetic for him since he got fired after winning the champions league and FA cup. I think the fans would take to him well.

If it were up to me, I'd go for Di Matteo. He may not be the right guy either, but he did great work with Chelsea and people feel sympathetic for him since he got fired after winning the champions league and FA cup. I think the fans would take to him well.
Seriously? There's a reason he's unemployed and not being linked to ANY jobs, never mind top jobs. He did what most chelsea managers do, and sat in the seat until he was fired. He stumbled into a champions league win which was even more of a fluke than the liverpool one when they came back from 3 down.
United need a manager, and Di Matteo isnt a manager.
They should go in for Mourinho.
Mourinho isn't moving.
And keep in mind I really don't care who gets the job. I hope the next guy is even worse. I just thought Di Matteo did a pretty good job and I'd like to see him get another shot to prove he wasn't as flukey as you're saying. That said, I'd also enjoy Ian Holloway getting the job.

Mourinho isn't moving.
And keep in mind I really don't care who gets the job. I hope the next guy is even worse. I just thought Di Matteo did a pretty good job and I'd like to see him get another shot to prove he wasn't as flukey as you're saying. That said, I'd also enjoy Ian Holloway getting the job.
He also ended the league season in a lower league place than he took over in.
It's no secret Jose wanted to go to United, and Chelsea wanted guardiola. I wouldn't be surprised to see it happen, especially after chels end the season empty handed.
Also doesn't help that he wasn't handed the best team in the league... this is probably one of the worst Man Utd teams we've seen for a while, and considering they won the league quite comfortably last season just goes to show how good Ferguson actually was. He got the best out of a bunch of players that would suit mid table teams, mixed with some world class players.
This is bullshit tbh, people keep saying it like it's true. Man United's team is a top 4 team, they have enough great players to challenge for the top 4, you could compare their team fairly to Arsenal and Liverpool. You don't win the league with a shit team regardless of who your manager is, you can't tell me this team's quality is 7th worthy. They're behind Spurs ffs!
It was a complete disaster, one I enjoyed, but a disaster nonetheless. He was way out of his depth and the payers weren't playing for him. He signed players for the sake of it and didn't know his best 11, United are better off without him I hate to say.


It's official, he's gone.

Also doesn't help that he wasn't handed the best team in the league... this is probably one of the worst Man Utd teams we've seen for a while, and considering they won the league quite comfortably last season just goes to show how good Ferguson actually was. He got the best out of a bunch of players that would suit mid table teams, mixed with some world class players.
This is bullshit tbh, people keep saying it like it's true. Man United's team is a top 4 team, they have enough great players to challenge for the top 4, you could compare their team fairly to Arsenal and Liverpool. You don't win the league with a shit team regardless of who your manager is, you can't tell me this team's quality is 7th worthy. They're behind Spurs ffs!
It was a complete disaster, one I enjoyed, but a disaster nonetheless. He was way out of his depth and the payers weren't playing for him. He signed players for the sake of it and didn't know his best 11, United are better off without him I hate to say.
Their strikers are class, love all four of them and I reckon all four could get into any top 4 team.
Defenders are getting old and ruined by injury. Ferdinand has looked average all season and you can tell the amount of injuries he's had are catching up on him. Smalling isn't top 4 quality. Evra is getting on, and there's no good back up for him. Rafael is good, but again, no back up for him. So defence isn't great.
Midfield, Anderson was shipped out because he's not developed like they'd hoped. Cleverly isn't that good, showed a lot of potential but not done much with it. Nani is amazingly inconsistent. Young isn't top 4 quality. Fellaini isn't top 4 quality and that's shown this season - looks good in a top 10 team, but not a top 4. Giggs is what, 40 now? Fletcher I think is great, but he's been out injured for about 2 years. Januzaj is young and looks like he has some great potential, but he's got some way to go yet. Valencia isn't top 4. Kagawa I like, but no where for him in the team really and we're yet to see whether he can adapt to the Prem. Carrick is class and could probably get into the top 4 teams. And everyone knows how good Mata is. So that's 2 midfielders that are really that good and could walk into another top 4 team.
De Gea I like, he's looked good last season and this season. But their aging and injury prone defence and poor midfield leaves a lot to be desired. Only their keepers and strikers are top 4 worthy really along with less than a handful of midfielders.
And Liverpool are about to win the league with a worst team than Chelsea and Man City. I'd even say the Arsenal team is better than Liverpools. That's just a credit to how well Rodgers has done there, getting them playing as a proper team unit and attacking exceptionally well. Liverpools team is like Man United's, it's not top 4 worthy. Some players are, but quite a lot of the team couldn't walk into a team like Chelsea, Arsenal or Man City. Shows what a good manager can do for a team. They can make average or good players look class.
See I could tear down every team in the top 4 the way you did just now, no team has 2 star payers in every position not even teams like Chelsea and City who've spent stupid amounts of their squads. If you compared these team at the beginning of the season you;d rate United much higher, Liverpool have shown what happens when your players play for the manager, star players perform and young players improve. None of that has happened at United and it's Moyes fault. He wasn't drawn a short hand he just didn't know how to play with the card's he was dealt with. This Man U team is top 4 quality.


You don't need 2 star men for every position, but 1 star man for each position would be good. They don't have 1 star man in every midfield position. Probably not even in their defence. Just shows the gap in managerial ability between Ferguson and Moyes, and that's my point. They should have a much better squad than they do, they've had much better in the past. Moyes was dealt a duff hand in that it's one of the weakest Man Utd teams in a while (apart from striker wise), but he's failed to show that he can carry on from Ferguson who showed that he was good enough to win a league without a top quality team. I'm not excusing Moyes, he's done shit. But the Man Utd squad is quite poor, especially if you compare it to Chelsea, Man City and Arsenal (Arsenals midfield is better than Man Utd's with the exception of Carrick and Mata).
Definitely should be able to get 5th with the players, but most aren't top 4 quality. Just like a good portion of Liverpools team isn't.
You look at Man Utd and Liverpool this season and the whole argument of how much influence a manager has on a team goes right out the window. Class players obviously helps, but managerial talent is needed to win games and finish in the top 4.
But the Man Utd squad is quite poor, especially if you compare it to Chelsea, Man City and Arsenal (Arsenals midfield is better than Man Utd's with the exception of Carrick and Mata)...
...You look at Man Utd and Liverpool this season and the whole argument of how much influence a manager has on a team goes right out the window. Class players obviously helps, but managerial talent is needed to win games and finish in the top 4.
Including Carrick and Mata you mean.
And we're basically agreeing here.


Reports are all over the internet saying that Moyes will be sacked within the next 24 hours following their woeful performance against Everton.
I like that they took a gamble on him instead of just going for someone with experience. People need to remember that there's only one way you can get experience, and that's to be given a chance. Guardiola's managerial experience when he took over Barcelona was their youth team. Mourinho managed a very small Portugese team before taking over Porto and winning the Europa League. It's not like Rodgers had more experience than Moyes when he took over Liverpool - granted, Rodgers plays much better football, but still, experience wise they've both done well with smaller clubs.
People need to be thrust into teams to gain the experience. Moyes is probably one of those managers that can do better with the smaller teams. We've seen them before, they can get smaller teams challenging for european places, but you put them in a top team and they can't do it. Same with players.
Also doesn't help that he wasn't handed the best team in the league... this is probably one of the worst Man Utd teams we've seen for a while, and considering they won the league quite comfortably last season just goes to show how good Ferguson actually was. He got the best out of a bunch of players that would suit mid table teams, mixed with some world class players.
So I feel sorry for Moyes really. Have done all season. Who ever followed Ferguson was always going to have a hard time of it because he was just that good. He didn't help himself though going in there and changing the backroom staff straight away mind you.
So, if he does get sacked within the next 24 hours like the reports are saying, who do you think they will go for? Someone with experience of managing a top team and who's won things, or give someone else a chance like a young upcoming manager who'd be able to get the best out of the players?
I've heard people wanting Klopp from Dortmund. He'd be good I reckon, he's done very well with them.
Comic Book News - Like the Facebook Page - Follow CBN on Twitter